‘BRUTAL TIMESHARE DICTATORS’ ARE FACING AN OWNERS’ REVOLUTION
Seasons Holidays bosses have been accused of using bullying, coercive tactics in attempts to control timeshare owners who are complaining about failures to deliver on ‘dream investment’ promises – now they have a fight on their hands.
Starting around 2008, and continuing to the present time, Seasons Holidays PLC started selling a ‘fractional timeshare’ product, called ‘Keys’. They sold it almost exclusively to their long-term, existing owners, telling them it was a product that everyone should want to buy – a co-ownership of a property, which had amazing benefits, including luxury holidays for 16 years, and a choice of either a payout (and potential profit), from the sale of the properties or 16 years more free holidays at the end of the contract – all with no annual fees. Some Seasons salespeople persuaded owners that Keys was so good that they should buy multiple products, and many did, often cashing in pensions, investments, or using life savings in expectation of substantial returns on their ‘property investment’.
‘WE MAKE THE RULES, AND CAN CHANGE WHAT WE WANT’
Even before the end of the contracts, many Seasons owners had expressed outrage when they were informed that Seasons had unilaterally downgraded them to what they referred to as ‘Core’ status, meaning their choices would be limited. They would not be able to stay in accommodation that had been ‘upgraded’. There was no consultation with the supposed co-owners who had invested millions into the Seasons business – but worse was to come.
Fast-forward to 2024, and those who paid up to £300,000 started to be told that the returns were not going to be as expected – and in fact, sales of the properties were likely to be so difficult, they would have to pay ‘upkeep fees’ for potentially years, with not even the benefit of being able to continue taking holidays. And the 16 years of free holidays option? Sorry – that’s no longer viable. Unsurprisingly, those who heard the news were distressed and started to complain, including getting organised on social media groups and leaving online reviews.
COMPLAINTS MET WITH HARDLINE ATTITUDE AND COERCIVE TECHNIQUES
Seasons had no sympathy with the distressed owners, many of whom are elderly, widowed, and suffering serious illnesses. They forced them to attend ‘end-of-contract’ meetings, which they said had to be face-to-face, which often involved travelling hundreds of miles. When they get to the meetings, Season sales staff – obviously on commission – confirmed the difficulties in selling the properties, the withdrawal of the 16-year extension option as promised, and the ongoing costs – but said that for an average additional £10,000, Seasons could take back the apparently failed Keys product and exchange it for a further 49 nights product they ironically call ‘Loyalty Nights’.
BANS AND EVICTIONS FOR ‘TROUBLEMAKERS’
Some owners who had helped organise a Facebook group, or who had made their feelings felt by leaving online reviews, were promptly banned – meaning they couldn’t even book the holidays they had paid for.
Owners who wanted to record the meetings they were forced into were also dealt with harshly – such recording is not permitted by Seasons. One couple, who had politely advised Seasons that they had made a recording for the purpose of reviewing what they had been told, were immediately evicted from their holiday accommodation. Even worse, a couple who hadn’t even finished their 2-week Seasons holiday in Lanzarote, having merely asked to record the meeting, were phoned later while enjoying dinner out and ordered to return to the resort to pack their bags and leave immediately. They pleaded with the resort staff to at least be allowed to stay overnight, so they could look for alternative accommodation in the morning, but were ushered out then and there. They managed to find a room that night – at their cost, but were so distressed, they booked flights to return home straight away – costing them more money. They also lost money on their curtailed car hire.
THE INTIMIDATION FACTOR
Many of those affected have said they were afraid to complain to Seasons after learning of the bans and evictions. Then, Seasons let it be known that they were monitoring the Facebook private group, so people felt they had to switch to anonymous posting – or simply stay quiet.
Next, Seasons instructed solicitors to threaten people who had described the situation with defamation claims.
“WE WILL NOT BE BULLIED”, SAY OWNERS
Hundreds of affected owners have chosen to fight back, and have contacted KwikChex, which has been investigating timeshare problems and assisting owners since 2013. Many others have commenced civil claims.
ONE OF THE WORST CASES EVER REPORTED
Chris Emmins, the CEO of KwikChex, says he has never seen behaviour quite as bad as this from a timeshare company. “Yes, there are often disputes, and even legal claims, but I’ve never seen conduct like this before”, said Emmins. “This isn’t a case of a few rogue salespeople; this is coming from the top, with Seasons director and owner Sharon Kinsella dictating the huge, unilaterally imposed, detrimental changes, additional charges, threats, and authorising her staff to impose bans and holiday evictions”.
OTHER SEASONS OWNERS FEEL THEY HAVE BEEN ROBBED OF THEIR TIMESHARES
Seasons owners who didn’t switch to the ‘Keys’ products have been forced out of their timeshare ownership at the Slaley Hall and Belton Woods resorts, with Seasons manipulating the owner voting rights in their favour, taking control of the owner committees and winding up the clubs, with Seasons then putting the properties on sale for huge sums. Many of these owners have also now asked KwikChex to intervene on their behalf.
KwikChex regards the situation as a travesty – the exploitation of long-term, loyal customers – and the matters have already been put to the authorities. KwikChex has confirmed that it is in urgent discussions with the authorities, including the Competition & Markets Authority (CMA) and the Department for Business & Trade, which has been asked to investigate the situation by Justin Madders, the Under-Secretary of State for Employment Rights, Competition, and Markets. Additionally, over 30 MPs have so far taken up the case on behalf of affected constituents.
KwikChex has been assessing what it believes to be multiple breaches of Consumer Protection Regulations (CPRs) and is pressing for urgent intervention, having received detailed reports and requests for assistance from over 200 Seasons owners.
A LACK OF COMMUNICATION
Seasons timeshare owners have recently experienced increased difficulties in contacting Season staff, with Seasons citing the cause as a fire that occurred at its Dylan Coastal resort, located in Carmarthen in January this year, which started in the laundry there, and has been said by Seasons to have affected its ability to respond to requests regarding payment of subletting money, data protection requests, holiday reservations, and general operations. The Seasons head office is in Bristol.
UTILITIES
Seasons has also refused to provide details of the calculations used in charging for utilities, including electricity. Several Seasons customers have felt that these charges have been excessive. The regulator, Ofgem, has advised that Seasons is legally obliged to provide a breakdown of electricity charges, and that Seasons isn’t permitted to impose any mark-ups on the amount charged to Seasons by the electricity provider.
LUXURY LODGES
In the case of the sales of lodges within its ‘Luxury’ portfolio, Seasons has been the subject of upheld complaints to the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) of misleading marketing.
It has also been reported that it is the same company, Luxury Lodge Estates Company Ltd, that is managing the sales of ‘standard’ properties, for example, at the Brunston Castle resort (now named Brunston Retreat by Seasons). The reports state that deposits secured by the properties are asked to be paid to ‘Luxury Lodges’.
Luxury Lodges Estates Company Ltd. is a registered company which has been dormant since its incorporation in 2015. Its sole director is Barry Hurley, chairman and director of Seasons Holidays.
Seasons Holidays has entered into significant commercial agreements with Landal, a major provider of holiday park rental accommodation. Several of the Seasons resorts now operate under the Landal brand, although the Luxury Lodges company and Seasons still exercise control over the properties. Landal has been given significant accommodation allocations at the Seasons resorts, which Seasons timeshare customers feel may be affecting the availability of accommodation they can book.
WHAT WE NOW KNOW
- There is strong evidence of consumer detriment. This is no longer based simply on a handful of dissatisfied owners. KwikChex has gathered substantial evidence from Seasons owners, documents, sales materials, financial information and other sources.
- Many owners are reporting remarkably similar experiences. These include concerns about how products were sold, what was said about fractional ownership and financial benefits, rental returns, service charges, availability, maturity, property sales and exit options.
- Some problems are already happening, not merely predicted. These include delayed or uncertain Keys maturity payments; concerns surrounding Brunston Castle and Club Tahiti; Knocktopher Castle and Lake; Garden and Park Collections; very poor rental outcomes; and, in some cases, a negative balance, with Seasons claiming it is owed money rather than a rental payment being made to owners. There is widespread concern about difficulties obtaining desired availability and justifiable uncertainty about what happens when products reach the end of their stated term, with a growing number of owners being told not to expect any financial return, or a meaningful 16-year ‘free holiday’ extension.
- Transparency is a major issue. Owners have been asking legitimate questions about rental calculations, charges, property values and sales, maturity payments and other matters affecting their ownership and finances, and these crucial questions have not been sufficiently answered by Seasons.
- The evidence is becoming stronger as more owners come forward. Where people who purchased at different resorts, at different times and from different salespeople independently describe similar representations and experiences, this is highly significant as it indicates what is known as ‘systemic misconduct’.
- The issues have already attracted national media scrutiny. BBC’s Rip Off Britain investigated Seasons’ fractional-ownership sales, including allegations of investment-style representations. KwikChex provided evidence and assistance to that investigation.
EXTREME DISTRESS
KwikChex has grave concerns about the plight of the affected owners and believes thousands may be affected.
The deeper we dig into this, the more concerned I become. I am talking to owners every day, many of whom are very vulnerable – several are suffering from serious and life-threatening medical conditions, many are in tears, and I have even had one couple tell me they are so distressed, they have contemplated suicide. Not a week goes by that I don’t learn of other problems, such as Seasons absolutely refusing to give owners a breakdown of annual service and utility charges. The lack of transparency and their hostile reactions to even the suggestion of recording their meetings with owners surely tells its own story – but there are robust laws in place to protect owners. We are determined to have the conduct of Seasons formally examined within the context of these laws, and to seek appropriate redress and justice on behalf of all those who have reached out to us for help.
Chris Emmins, KwikChex CEO