Skip to main content Scroll Top

What happened to our ‘unique’ holiday + investment dream?

What happened to our ‘unique’ holiday + investment dream? 

That’s the question Seasons Holidays owners are asking after buying products presented as combining luxury holidays, property-related benefits and potentially substantial financial returns. So why are so many now saying they cannot obtain the holidays they expected, their financial benefits have collapsed, and their retirement plans have been wrecked? 

A KWIKCHEX INVESTIGATION  & BRIEFING 

THE SCALE OF THE ISSUE 
Based on the evidence presently available, KwikChex estimates that the total value of the relevant Seasons contracts sold may exceed £150 million. KwikChex is directly assisting more than 200 Seasons owners, has identified 38 different contract types to date, and understands that at least another 200 owners have commenced civil actions. Requests for assistance continue to grow. 

Overview and impact 

For years, the proposition presented to Seasons Holidays customers appeared extraordinarily attractive. 

Enjoy years of high-quality holidays. Avoid the burden of ever-increasing annual maintenance charges. Benefit from an interest linked to valuable holiday property. Earn good money from subletting. And, after 16 years, potentially receive a substantial financial return — or enjoy a further 16 years of holidays. 

It was a combination of lifestyle and financial benefits that persuaded many people to pay tens of thousands, even hundreds of thousands, of pounds. 

For some, the money came from savings accumulated over a lifetime. Several used pension funds. Others borrowed. Existing timeshare owners were persuaded to surrender or trade in products they already owned and pay substantial additional sums to move into Seasons’ new products. 

Many purchasers are now retired or approaching retirement. For a growing number of them, the dream has turned into something very different. 

KwikChex is assisting Seasons owners who describe being distraught, angry and frightened. Some say the prolonged stress is seriously affecting their wellbeing. KwikChex staff have also supported people who have said they contemplated suicide. Increasingly, owners are saying that retirement plans built around the benefits they expected from these products have been shattered. 

As the earliest 16-year contracts reach maturity, a new reality is emerging. Some owners whose contracts expired as far back as 2023 are still waiting to receive maturity payments. Others who say they were attracted by forecasts of subletting income are reporting collapsing returns, unexpected charges and even negative balances. Many also describe being invited to meetings in which the proposed solution involves paying Seasons even more money. 

This is no longer simply a dispute about whether a holiday product represented good value. 

There are serious questions about what consumers were told they were buying, what they were led to expect would happen, and what is actually happening now. 

The proposition: property, luxury holidays and financial returns 

One of the most important products at the centre of the controversy is Seasons Holidays’ Keys products. KwikChex has gathered extensive evidence concerning how Keys and subsequent Seasons products were marketed and sold. 

Owners repeatedly describe Keys as having been presented as fundamentally different from conventional timeshare. Purchasers could enjoy holiday accommodation for 16 years while avoiding the conventional timeshare burden of escalating annual maintenance fees. But that was only part of the attraction: the product was also connected explicitly to property. 

Historic sales material examined during the BBC’s Rip Off Britain investigation included statements such as: 

“You own a share of a property.” 

“You can genuinely expect to buy today and sell in the future at a profit.” 

The BBC programme reported Seasons’ position that it never marketed Keys as an investment and that profit was not promoted as a reason for buying the product. 

That distinction is now one of the central issues requiring scrutiny. Whatever terminology appeared in the contractual documentation, KwikChex has heard from a substantial number of consumers whose recollection is remarkably consistent: they believed they were acquiring something connected to property that would provide both excellent holidays and significant financial value. 

For consumers whose total spending has, in some cases, exceeded £300,000, that distinction matters enormously. 

The Brunston Castle early warning 

The case is complex in both nature and scale, involving dozens of contract types, thousands of consumers, and many millions of pounds. But the earliest sales help put the later problems into focus, and perhaps nowhere is this clearer than at Brunston Castle in Scotland. 

Seasons began selling its new proposition in 2007 at Brunston Castle, where the earliest products were presented as involving ‘co-ownership’ connected with freehold properties. Those earliest 16-year terms reached maturity in December 2023. 

Yet KwikChex is assisting owners whose contracts ended then and who, more than two and a half years later, have received no maturity payment. Many say their understanding was straightforward: at maturity, the relevant properties would be valued and sold and they would receive their appropriate share of the net proceeds. 

The BBC’s Rip Off Britain programme featured precisely this problem, including the case of an owner still awaiting a payout more than two years after her membership ended. 

As is so often the case when there is media exposure of detriment, the day before the programme was aired, Seasons confirmed that the featured couple would receive a substantial payment – perhaps not what they were expecting, but at least it brought their difficulties to an end.  

KwikChex CEO, Chris Emmins, who regularly appears on BBC investigation programmes as a consumer advocacy expert, appeared on the show and helped lay bare the problems facing those in similar circumstances. KwikChex also investigated the specific circumstances and found that others who invested earlier than the featured consumers have still not been paid. 

Seasons points to substantial problems selling the Brunston Castle Lodges, but that is a far cry from how they presented it as an attractive investment opportunity – and Seasons are currently enticing potential buyers of the lodges under the new brand ‘Brunston Country Retreat’ with phrases such as ‘Alongside lifestyle appeal, owners can benefit from a buy-to-let opportunity with net rental returns of up to £32,791 per year, making Brunston equally attractive as a countryside retreat or a considered investment.’ 

KwikChex also discovered that, in one case involving a lodge that had been sold, Keys investors in that lodge were not informed of the sale until KwikChex raised the matter. Hutchinson Trustees subsequently confirmed the sale. Payment was offered almost a year after the property was sold. No satisfactory explanation for the payment delay has been provided by Hutchinson Trustees or Seasons. 

In the same case, one couple who should have received payment by the end of 2024 were subsequently subjected to pressure to trade in their existing product and pay approximately another £10,000 — months after their lodge had already been sold. KwikChex intervened before that further purchase took place. 

In filed accounts for the extended period to 30 June 2015, Seasons Holidays PLC stated: “During this period the group recognised income of £7,304,074 in respect of fractional sales at Brunston Castle.”

That’s one product in one (extended) financial year, the clearest indication of how much profit Seasons has been making from sales of over 30 such products for going on 20 years – and we already know what has happened in the case of Brunston. 

What’s happening at Brunston Castle right now?

According to recent updates from Hutchinson Trustees, the resort is ‘now closed’ to Seasons owners. Yet lodges continue to be offered to the retail market for holiday rental and Seasons continues to promote outright lodge ownership there.  

Problems across the board 

Brunston Castle is the earliest example, not the only one. KwikChex is receiving complaints and evidence concerning products and changes across the Seasons portfolio. 

Keys / fractional locations 

• Laugharne Park, now rebranded as Dylan Coastal Resort, Carmarthenshire 

• Brunston Castle, now rebranded as Brunston Country Retreat, South Ayrshire 

• Whitbarrow Village, Cumbria 

• Burn Park, now rebranded as Bude Coastal Resort, Cornwall 

• Seaham Hall, County Durham 

• Slaley Hall, Northumberland 

• Forest Hills Estepona, Spain 

• Club Tahiti, Lanzarote, Spain 

• Knocktopher Abbey, County Kilkenny, Ireland 

• Clowance Estate, Cornwall 

Other fractional products 

• The Lake Collection 

• The Garden Collection 

• The Park Collection 

Other disputed changes and products 

• Traditional timeshare at Belton Woods and Slaley Hall, where owners have complained about unilateral cancellation or removal of timeshare rights while properties are marketed for other purposes. 

• ‘Seasons Core Owners’ — a status introduced by Seasons which owners say demoted them to a more basic accommodation level and prevented access to the luxury standards they believed they had purchased. 

• ‘Loyalty Nights’ — a product used in circumstances where owners say their Keys holdings were portrayed as potential liabilities and they were offered an ‘escape’ by paying a further £10,000 or more. 

What happened to the additional 16 years of holidays? 

Earlier representations and documentation described choices available when the initial period ended. These included taking proceeds associated with the property sale or continuing for a further 16 years of holidays. 

Yet what many owners approaching the end of their contracts are now being told bears little resemblance to the proposition they remember purchasing. Instead, they describe meetings in which they are warned about poor property values, ongoing costs, and other disadvantages — followed by proposals for replacement products that require substantial additional payments. 

The apparent disappearance or substantial alteration of the further 16-year holiday option is therefore not a minor contractual detail. It was a material benefit capable of influencing a consumer’s decision to spend tens of thousands of pounds. If the benefit has been devalued to the point that the original proposition no longer exists, that affects every purchaser who relied upon it, regardless of which option they ultimately intended to choose. 

The promised holiday benefits have changed beyond recognition 

The controversy does not stop with maturity payments. KwikChex has received reports concerning availability, membership status and restrictions on accommodation owners previously believed they would be able to access. 

Owners who expected years of premium holidays across the Seasons portfolio question why accommodation can be available to retail holidaymakers while their own ability to obtain desirable accommodation has become increasingly restricted. 

Many owners say they can no longer book at a substantial proportion of the resorts originally available to them because Seasons has sold whole resorts or significant numbers of properties, or because long-standing customers have been placed into lower membership categories and told they no longer have access to ‘luxury standard’ accommodation. 

That is particularly difficult to accept when the quality and flexibility of the holidays were among the principal reasons for purchasing. 

The rental and subletting detriment worsens 

Subletting was a crucial factor for many purchasers — particularly those who bought multiple products not primarily to holiday, but to rent out. 

KwikChex has seen an extraordinary and disturbing situation develop. Rental income reported to owners has declined, and payments have arrived progressively later. Some 2025 rental payments were delayed for months. Owners have subsequently been told that returns have fallen so far that some, instead of receiving money, have negative balances and are said to owe Seasons money. 

The figures supplied to owners using the Seasons subletting service do not provide the underlying occupancy, gross rental and deduction information needed to independently verify the calculations. Seasons has referred to factors including market conditions, competition and adverse publicity. Owners have responded with an obvious question: if rental performance has been so poor, why do they themselves struggle to obtain availability? 

New subletting arrangements have intensified the concern. Seasons emphasises that no return is guaranteed and that the product must not be considered an investment. Owners also say they cannot obtain the detailed breakdowns needed to test the figures. For some contracts, the practical choice appears stark: agree to subletting without knowing whether it will produce any income — and potentially end with a negative balance — or refuse and face service charges. 

Owners say this is irreconcilable with the way the financial potential was presented when they purchased. KwikChex has documentary evidence supporting their contention, including ‘Return on Investment’ spreadsheets used in the sales process that projected rental returns and end-of-contract payments and compared the outcome with leaving money in a bank deposit account. 

How has Seasons responded? 

Seasons has made its position clear. 

Seasons has categorically denied that Keys was marketed as an investment or that profit was promoted as a reason to purchase.  

After giving strong indications of substantial rental returns, Seasons is now effectively confirming owners using the subletting process could get nothing at all – but that’s not their problem. 

Having initially adopted a policy of coercing people into paying money to exit the fractional investment products, Seasons is now offering a flat £1000 to anyone who wishes to do so. By Seasons’ own admission, this isn’t based on any form of compensatory formula; it’s just: ‘We will give you £1,000 to give up the dream we sold you and you will have no more rights or say in the matter’. 

Seasons has shown they have no regard for the position they have put so many people in, and say they won’t accept any blame. 

When faced with stronger criticism, the dispute has become more confrontational. KwikChex has received evidence of threats of defamation and of owners being restricted or banned after public criticism or disputes over recordings of meetings. KwikChex is also aware of cases involving removal from holiday accommodation. 

KwikChex CEO Chris Emmins says: “This is bullying, pure and simple. Notably, the only action Seasons took when the couple appeared on the BBC was to quickly make a substantial payment to them. For me, that epitomises the nature of a bully.” 

KwikChex has warned Seasons’ solicitors of the potential for formal complaints concerning such conduct and intends to include relevant evidence in the matters being pursued with authorities. 

It’s not the fault of those who invested 

It is common for people who suffer serious financial detriment to blame themselves, and for outsiders to dismiss them with the phrase ‘if it’s too good to be true, it probably is’. That ignores a crucial feature of this case: many affected owners were already long-standing Seasons customers. 

They had enjoyed Seasons holidays. They knew staff. They trusted the company. Many say the new products were introduced while they were on holiday and presented as the answer to the disadvantages of traditional timeshares: rising annual fees, very long commitments, and poor exit prospects. 

The proposition owners describe was compelling: move away from old-fashioned timeshare into something connected with freehold property; continue enjoying holidays; avoid annual fees; potentially earn rental income; rely on trustees to protect the property arrangements; and, after 16 years, receive the benefit of a property sale or continue holidaying. 

How much money is involved? 

Seasons has sold contracts of these types over nearly two decades. KwikChex has identified 38 different contract types to date and has received purchase information from hundreds of consumers. 

One unusually clear benchmark appears in Seasons’ own filed accounts: £7.304 million of income was recognised in a single extended accounting period ‘in respect of fractional sales at Brunston Castle’. Brunston was only one resort and one part of a much broader sales programme. 

Based on the evidence presently available to it, KwikChex estimates that the total value of the relevant contracts sold by Seasons may exceed £150 million. This is a KwikChex estimate, not a figure reported by Seasons, and will be refined as further documentary evidence is analysed. 

Industry bodies decline to intervene 

KwikChex originally contacted Seasons directors and offered to discuss how the emerging problems might be resolved. Seasons directors subsequently accused KwikChex of bullying them. 

KwikChex then provided evidence to the Resort Development Organisation (RDO), the European timeshare trade organisation whose members include Seasons Holidays and which operates a code of conduct. KwikChex was informed by the RDO chairman that the RDO board had evaluated the matter and declined to take meaningful action. 

KwikChex also approached EUROC, which describes itself as an independent, not-for-profit timeshare trade association focused on consumer protection. EUROC declined to assist and referred the matters to RDO. KwikChex considers the relationships between industry bodies relevant context when assessing whether owners have had access to effective independent industry redress. 

Owners turn to authorities and the courts 

With no effective industry resolution, affected owners are increasingly seeking remedies through regulators, enforcement bodies and the courts. 

KwikChex is collating and analysing thousands of pages of documents and statements from more than 200 Seasons owners via its Direct Assistance service and is submitting this evidence to UK authorities. The Department for Business & Trade has been helping to coordinate matters and has advised that several MPs have contacted the minister. 

KwikChex has also established that at least another 200 owners have commenced civil actions using legal representation, and that a lead case has recently been referred to the High Court after initially being presented in the County Court. 

Requests for assistance continue to grow. KwikChex is also assisting a Facebook community of more than 1,200 owners who are deeply concerned about the situation. 

Summary from Chris Emmins 

I have taken the lead in many timeshare cases for over a decade, working with authorities and the media, and supporting civil and criminal cases to help right wrongs and ensure justice is served. This is one of the most significant. The disdain and lack of compassion shown by Seasons in the face of compelling evidence is extraordinary. Seasons owners deserve more. They deserve to receive what they were so obviously promised. They deserve justice. KwikChex has taken up this fight, and will pursue it all the way. 

Contact KwikChex 

Any Seasons owner affected by these issues can contact KwikChex free of charge to discuss their situation and the options available. General advice is provided without charge. Owners who require more detailed case-specific assistance can also ask about KwikChex’s Direct Assistance service. 

Timeshare Assistance contact form: https://timeshareassistance.com/contact/  

Email: info@kwikchex.com