While KwikChex was continuing to evaluate the situation, including within the context of whether Seasons and their products had complied with the relevant laws, a growing number of Seasons Holidays customers were being pressured into attending meetings with Seasons to discuss their end-of-term options. The stated contractual time for the decision to be made by the owners of the fractional products between what had been described as ‘Option 1’ – taking a share of the proceeds of sale of the properties within the fractional schemes, and ‘Option 2’ – taking a further 16 years of ‘charge-free’, ‘luxury holidays’ is in the fifteenth year of the contract – but many being pressed to attend the meetings had two years or more before the fifteenth year was reached. Despite many pointing this out to Seasons, and stating that they wished to wait until that point, and also that they felt a face-to-face meeting was unnecessary and was inconvenient, Seasons continued to apply pressure for people to attend these meetings.
At these meetings, the majority of those KwikChex has been in contact with have testified that they were advised that a) the amount they would receive as their share of the proceeds of the sale was considerably lower than purchasers had been expecting, b) that the properties were likely to be difficult to sell, and while the sales process was ongoing, charges would be applied, and c) that the 16-year ‘rollover’ (option 2) now had fundamentally changed so much, it had little value.
The majority of the Seasons’ customers who attended these meetings were advised that a new option had been introduced, which involved handing back (in a ‘part-exchange’ arrangement) the fractional products (which had been sold as a product that ‘all timeshare owners would want to have’, and which included the potential to make a profit, but now were being portrayed as an ongoing liability), and then paying Seasons another large sum for a new product.
Seasons confirmed that Option 2 – the 16-year, free of charges rollover, is a) now restricted to only three resorts, b) substantial surcharges would apply at other resorts, c) some resorts would not be available at all, d) availability would be a significant issue, e) accommodation would be restricted to the smallest capacity, and the lowest grade of accommodation, and f) that charges could be applied by Seasons for the ongoing costs of unsold properties associated with the original fractional contract. This is significantly and materially different from what was indicated at the time of sale.
Under pressure, Seasons subsequently retracted their statements concerning ongoing charges during the sales period – but there remains no reasonable doubt that this aspect was used as a pressure point in the meetings. Some attendees did succumb to the pressure, giving up their fractional contracts and paying thousands more for a new product. Refund requests and reinstatement of the original contracts have been refused by Seasons.
WHAT WE NOW KNOW
We know (from what can only be described as indisputable evidence) that Seasons encouraged people to consider fractional products as financial investments, yet Seasons now denies this. They are saying you shouldn’t expect a good financial return, and any payment could take a very long time after the contracts end.
We know that everyone sold Keys, was promised the option of a 16-year free holiday extension, and that Seasons has changed this crucial promise so much that it is worthless. That means that everyone has suffered this detriment, even if they weren’t actively considering the option.
BRUNSTON CASTLE
We know that Brunston is stuck in a ‘sales quagmire’, and even when units have been sold, it has taken substantial pressure from KwikChex’s actions to get owners paid a share of the proceeds of sale. People have been waiting for up to two and a half years since their contract term ended.
CLUB TAHITI
We know that Club Tahiti apartments have had to be withdrawn from sale due to legal matters and difficulties, leaving Keys owners (some of whom have contracts that have already passed their 16-year term) in limbo. This information has not been disclosed to the Club Tahiti Keys owners.
KNOCKTOPHER ABBEY
We know that Knocktopher was taken out of the trust system to be sold at auction, without any notification or consultation with the Keys owners (the trust beneficiaries), and that despite being sold in May, owners haven’t even been told by Hutchinson what they will receive (although Seasons has previously indicated it will be very little).